Why Suffering Isn't Always Enough to Change a Situation

I frequently encounter a seemingly paradoxical situation: a person is suffering. Sometimes profoundly so. Their life is filled with pain, dissatisfaction, and dead ends. One would think this would serve as the ultimate catalyst for change. Yet, it doesn't. The situation drags on, the pain deepens, and still, no action is taken.

Why is that?

From a Gestalt perspective, suffering is merely a signal—an organismic cry indicating that something is amiss, that balance has been disrupted, and that a vital need remains unfulfilled. However, this signal alone is not always enough to trigger transformation. Here are several reasons why this happens:

1. The comfort of the familiar.

The most powerful trap is the comfort of what we already know. The unknown is far more terrifying than familiar pain. To conserve energy, the brain favors a tested (albeit painful) script simply because it is predictable.

2. Secondary gains (hidden benefits).

This is not conscious manipulation, but a deeply unconscious process. Suffering often serves a vital function in our lives. It can be a source of attention and sympathy from loved ones, a justification for inaction ("I can't do it because I feel so awful"), or a way to shield oneself from even deeper pain or responsibility. By relinquishing the suffering, a person fears losing these underlying "perks."

3. Change is always accompanied by loss.

Transformation requires letting go—the loss of a piece of one's identity (Who am I without this role or this problem?), the loss of familiar relationships (even if they are codependent), or the loss of a particular way of life. This potential loss is perceived as a threat, driving us to cling to what we have—even when it causes us pain.

4. Unfinished business of the past (unfinished Gestalts).

People often get stuck in suffering because they subconsciously re-enact old scenarios, attempting to bring closure to something that remains painful and unresolved from their past. Suffering becomes an (albeit ineffective) attempt to process a past that demands attention and integration.

5. A lack of holistic awareness.

Sometimes we feel pain but cannot fully pinpoint its source or connect it to specific actions (or inaction). We fail to see how we ourselves participate in creating our own suffering. Until this awareness becomes complete, vivid, and felt at a deep level, taking action feels either impossible or pointless.

6. "I should" versus "I want."

As long as change is perceived as an obligation (imposed by society, loved ones, or an inner critic), it triggers internal resistance. A genuine desire to change stems from a heartfelt "I want"—the authentic wish to live differently and feel differently. It is this desire that fuels the momentum to move forward.

——————————

What can be done?

Rather than simply acknowledging the fact of suffering, it is essential to engage in deeper self-inquiry:

• What am I truly afraid of if change actually happens?

• What do I gain by staying in this suffering? What function does it serve for me right now?

• What old narratives or patterns are playing out in my current situation?

• What is my own contribution to creating and maintaining this situation?

• What do I actually want?